August 24, 2011

Economists and the Broken Window Fallacy

There has been a notable increase in the advocacy for some sort of disaster to befall the country in order to create a boom in post-disaster rebuilding.  This is an error that is known as the "broken windows fallacy", which refers to a parable in which Bastiat proved that repeatedly breaking a shopkeeper's window to force him to repair it was not ultimately economically stimulative.

For example, Paul "what we need now is a housing bubble" Krugman has been suggesting war, alien invasion, and most recently expressed disappointment that the recent East Coast earthquake did not cause more damage. I see little mention of the effects of the Japanese tsunami and nuclear meltdown.  According to the damage-is-good hypothesis, Japan should be enjoying a rebuilding boom.  Instead, its economy has been depressed since the tsunami event.  This is not surprising when you consider that massive amounts of assets and therefore capital was destroyed, but the Keynesian blind spot with respect to balance sheets prevents its advocates from understanding what really happens when you destroy infrastructure.

August 09, 2011

Joe Gagnon Says Print Big Money Until the Patient Recovers

Former Fed official Joe Gagnon has a posting that is making the rounds.  Basically he says stop futzing around and start printing dough like mad until all is right with the world.  Currency devaluation will help exports (except if everybody else does it too).  It reduces the value of existing debt.  Lowers your cholesterol.

He tops it off by showing that he still believes in the Philips curve despite its spectacular failure in the 1970s:
Inflation will never increase to a significant extent as long as unemployment lingers at this elevated level.
See, the key is that magic fairies transmute monetary inflation into employment and growth, according to the Philips curve and its dressed-up successor the imaginary NAIRU.

Risk of too much inflation?  Bah, we can quit anytime:
[...] the Federal Reserve could assuage the fears of the inflation hawks by stating clearly that its policy would be rapidly reversed in the unlikely event that core inflation rises above 3 percent on a sustained basis 
I'm sure everyone will believe the Fed at its word.  Massive money printing.  What could go wrong?  It's worked great historically, right?

August 08, 2011

It's the Fraud!

With worldwide markets going down in flames, the punditsphere is atwitter with attempts to change the narrative to the need for fiscal stimulus programs to create jobs.  Keynesian prayers won't save us now.

We are here because of an accumulation of financial fraud over decades by corrupt parties, and investors have lost confidence in the legitimacy of the game.  Stock markets are dominated by HFT algos, dark pools, and other shady casino operators.  Central banks are monetizing government debt in broad daylight, while handing largesse to favored banks, hedge funds, and any other players with influence.  Tax loopholes let corporations and the wealthy avoid taxation.  Financial players create unsecured credit at will and dump losses on the taxpayer if their plans go south.  Banks sold fake mortgage securities to investors and try to foreclose on homes they don't own.  Bonds have been turned into exotic synthetic instruments like CDS that represent bets instead of real investment in productive activities, and CDS writers find ways of avoiding payouts or dumping liability on the taxpayer.  Finally, the only thing that economists from Alan Greenspan to Paul Krugman agree on is that governments can just print money indefinitely.

We are here because of a total breakdown in the rule of law and the integrity of currencies.  The masses have lost faith in the legal system that is supposed to protect them from financial fraud.  They are now voting with their bank accounts.

August 07, 2011

S&P Sticks Its Neck Out; Government Parasites Freak Out

S&P has been threatening for months to downgrade the US credit rating and it finally did it.  Elites of all political stripes united to condemn them for daring to say the emperor has no clothes.  The reason you should pay attention to S&P is that they took this action at great political cost to themselves--governments in Europe are talking about stripping their ratings agency monopolies and replacing them with a pliant government ratings committee.  S&P bit the hand that feeds it at great political cost to itself.  This is a first step towards restoring the ratings agencies' credibility and should be respected.

Instead, the elites are howling about the agencies having no credibility and should just keep quiet.

Much is being made of a supposed error S&P made in referencing CBO deficit projections.  Essentially, they used a particular bogus CBO forecast when the CBO would have preferred they used a different inaccurate forecast.  This is obviously neither here nor there, but is being used to try to create doubt around S&P's downgrade or imply that they will withdraw it.

Hell hath no fury like a government bureaucrat (or academic) whose umbilical cord is being threatened.

August 05, 2011

The Debt Ceiling Deal Saved Us From Financial Catastrophe

To all those who were forecasting crashing markets if the US debt ceiling wasn't raised:

Ok, so the debt ceiling was raised and we got crashing markets anyway.  I thought the Tea Partiers were terrorists playing brinksmanship with the economy.  How come the deal didn't save us?

July 11, 2011

Austerity and Wasting Money

#8 The U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs spent $175 million during 2010 to maintain hundreds of buildings that it does not even use.  This includes a pink, octagonal monkey house in the city of Dayton, Ohio.
#16 A professor at Dartmouth University received $137,530 to create a "recession-themed" video game entitled "Layoff". 
Finding examples of government waste like this is like shooting fish in a barrel.  That said, in the big picture, dubious projects like this really don't amount to that much in the overall government budget.  Even if all of the waste were eliminated, healthcare costs and other so-called entitlement spending are scheduled to overwhelm us anyway.  So why bring it up?

Well apparently it's common economics knowledge that "you don't cut government spending in the middle of a recession".  That spending adds to GDP, and so eliminating it contracts the economy.  So by this theory, that esteemed professor from Dartmouth will spend his $137,530 into the economy and promote growth, which is good.  If he didn't get it, we won't get the economic multiplier effect, tax receipts will go down, and such "austerity" measures will ultimately be self-defeating and not actually save the government money.  Keynes famously said that at some point it doesn't matter if the government paid people to dig holes and fill them in again, the government (i.e. fiscal policy) needs to inject money into the economy to promote demand.

Those who question this point of view are being labeled promoters of "austerity".

To the extent that there are public investment opportunities that will provide positive economic or social return, and we are in a very favorable interest rate environment for the government to borrow in, then government should clearly make the investment.  There are any number of "big idea" national initiatives that fit the criteria of a positive return:
  • Modernization of the air traffic control system
  • Roadway and bridge infrastructure repair
  • High-speed rail between economically sustainable routes (major metros 200-500 miles apart)
  • Nationwide wireless and fiber communications infrastructure available to the public
  • Revamped educational system including trade schools, public school choice modeled after European and Asian systems
  • Universal day care
  • Grant programs to add 1,000,00 new general practice doctors
  • Healthcare reform that breaks the health insurance oligopoly that runs up costs in the US--if nationalizing the industry is the answer, then it needs to be done
  • A publicly-owned sustainable power grid to reduce the cost of electric power, transmission losses and dependency on fossil fuels and central power plants
  • Execute one of the great water diversion projects (see GRAND and NAWAPA) to divert water from Canada and end the US West's water shortages forever
Instead, proponents of Keynesian fiscal policy mostly defend transfer payments, rebates for various politically correct behaviors, and the occasional "shovel-ready" construction project.  Whatever it takes to fill the supposed "demand gap" in the short term, by use of the national credit card as necessary.  This isn't a good use of resources.

To those who would say we can't afford it--it's always a good time to make a sound investment.  Separate bonds could be sold to fund the infrastructure projects (much like municipal bonds or even WWII war bonds) separate from the general fund, and the investment would be a no-brainer due to the obvious return on investment.  To those who worry about government crowding out private enterprise--what's wrong with government taking resources to fund worthwhile projects?  Also, capital for good private enterprise is always available, at worst government may take up resources that might have otherwise ended up in marginal enterprises like Pets.com.

The neo-Keynesian focus on spending-for-spending's sake in order to pump up the short-term economy with ephemeral consumer spending is foolhardy.  The GDP equation regards spending and investment as synonymous, but in the long-term, investment without future returns is a waste of resources.  I'm all for what economist Joseph Stiglitz calls a "well-designed stimulus" package that invests in the future.  But the Keynesians don't do themselves any favors when they just focus on filling the "demand gap" with mindless short-term fiscal spending that has zero long-term returns--we owe it to future generations to invest present resources wisely.

June 30, 2011

St. Freddie and St. Fannie

Brad DeLong and other commentators seem to have an unnecessary need to prove that Fannie and Freddie's hands were clean with respect to the credit crisis.  The Republican narrative about the mortgage crisis originating with government forcing lenders to loan to unqualified minorities is indeed a bunch of nonsense; the volume of those programs never amounted to anything and subprime borrowers had no particular racial skew.  However, Freddie and Fannie played a significant role in the mortgage crisis because they enabled the market bubble to grow so big.

Fannie and Freddie are $5 trillion dollars worth of the mortgage market.  Their "implicit government guarantee" allowed them to operate at 200:1 leverage ratios, which blew up when not only their subprime portfolio did, but also when their conforming mortgages delinquency skyrocketed.  Fannie and Freddie bought hundreds of billions  worth of subprime and Alt-A-backed securities, which made them a big part of the market for Wall Street to sell their CDO sausages to.

Now, to their credit, the GSEs never touched the most egregious loans like no-docs, "liar loans", and the like that raged at the top of the bubble.  That stuff was the true toxic waste.  But the fact is, the GSEs are in conservatorship right now, pushing losses of tens of billions of dollars a quarter onto the taxpayer, because they took on too much risk with too little capital buffers.  That is what caused this crisis, and Fannie and Freddie definitely contributed to the problem.

June 27, 2011

What They Never Told You About "Comparative Advantage"

"If there were an Economist’s Creed, it would surely contain the affirmations 'I understand the Principle of Comparative Advantage' and 'I advocate Free Trade'."
-Paul Krugman
David Ricardo first articulated the concept of comparative advantage in 1817.  In a nutshell, it suggests a happy world where each country is better at producing some goods than others, and it pays for each country to specialize in producing goods in which it has the greatest comparative advantage.  In the classic example, Portgual can product both cloth and wine at 90 and 80 labor units, while England can produce them at 100 and 110 respectively.  Even though Portugal is the low-cost producer in both instances, there is more relative profit in wine (30) than in cloth (10), so collectively Portugal can trade wine for English cloth and both parties profit from the relationship.  How all of this magically balances out trade deficits and improves quality of life for everyone is an article of faith within the Economists' Creed.

A key assumption that Ricardo made is today ignored by modern economists:
" ... if capital freely flowed towards those countries where it could be most profitably employed, there could be no difference in the rate of profit, and no other difference in the real or labour price of commodities, than the additional quantity of labour required to convey them to the various markets where they were to be sold."
Guess what?  Capital flows freely around the world today, to every country, except oddballs like North Korea.  Mobile capital seeks cheap labor, cheap land, lax regulatory rules, and low taxes.  Therefore "comparative advantage" is now a race to the bottom for labor, environmental regulation, and progressive taxation.  With free capital, Portugal's low labor costs can now produce both wine and cloth and drive English businesses out entirely.

Modern economists look back upon the 19th century United States with disdain, a country that had booms and busts, no social safety net, little government economic intervention, and no central bank.  It was also strongly protectionist, starting with Alexander Hamilton and maintained by the Whig and later Republican parties.  This was known as the American System, which stood in contrast to the free trade-oriented British System.  These terms are quaint today, but the conflicting worldviews can still be identified in modern free trade debate.

Tariff rates bounced around from a low in 1857 of 18%, to 40-50% that was characteristic of the Gilded Age.  Abraham Lincoln raised tariffs to 49% during the US Civil War.  During the period 1865-1890, America experienced the most rapid growth of its entire existence, hitting 6.8% annual GDP growth and doubling its GDP during the 1880s.  By 1890, in but 100 years, America had eclipsed Great Britain as the world's largest industrial power.  Commitment to protectionism then began to falter, leading to conflict between free trade Democrats and protectionist Republicans.  Future President William McKinley said of this:
"Under free trade the trader is the master and the producer the slave. Protection is but the law of nature, the law of self-preservation, of self-development, of securing the highest and best destiny of the race of man. [It is said] that protection is immoral…. Why, if protection builds up and elevates 63,000,000 [the U.S. population] of people, the influence of those 63,000,000 of people elevates the rest of the world. We cannot take a step in the pathway of progress without benefiting mankind everywhere. Well, they say, ‘Buy where you can buy the cheapest'…. Of course, that applies to labor as to everything else. Let me give you a maxim that is a thousand times better than that, and it is the protection maxim: ‘Buy where you can pay the easiest.' And that spot of earth is where labor wins its highest rewards."
 McKinley successfully passed  through Congress a namesake tariff act in 1890.  To its critics in retrospect he commented:
"What has this Protective Tariff law of 1890 done? Why, it has increased factories all over the United States. It has built new ones, it has enlarged old ones.... [For example, we] used to buy our buttons made in Austria by the prison labor of Austria. We are buying our buttons today made by the free labor of America. We had 11 button factories before 1890; we have 85 now. We employed 500 men before 1890, at from $12 to $15 a week; we employ 8,000 men now, at from $18 to $35 a week."...|Well, but, they said, this tariff law of 1890 was going to increase the price of necessaries of life, and was going to diminish the wages of labor. It has done neither. The necessities of life are cheaper today than they were 18 months ago. The commodities that go into the household of every man and woman are cheaper today ... and the price of labor has increased to some extent."
Contrast this today with those who told us NAFTA and MFN status for China would create American jobs.  Do any pundits today set higher wages and lower product costs as a policy goal today?  No, we are told that higher wages leads to bad "price spiral" inflation, but higher product costs reflect more "quality", demand growth, and other positive things.

McKinley had this to say about land owenership:
``We must avoid in this country the holding of large tracts of land by non-resident owners for speculative purposes, and set our faces like flint against alien land-holding in small or large tracts. Our public domain must be re-dedicated to our own people, and neither foreign syndicates nor domestic corporations must be permitted to divert it from the hallowed purposes of actual settlement by real farmers."
You don't expect to hear Republicans talking like Marxist land reformers.  No doubt the Monsantos of the world are happy to keep this bit of US history dead.

Henry Carey, advisor to President Lincoln and a forgotten economist who promoted the American System, expressed some loftier goals for the battle between the American and British systems:
``Two systems are before the world; the one looks to increasing the proportion of persons and of capital engaged in trade and transportation, and therefore to diminishing the proportion engaged in producing commodities with which to trade, with necessarily diminished return to the labour of all; while the other looks to increasing the proportion engaged in the work of production, and diminishing that engaged in trade and transportation, with increased return to all, giving to the labourer good wages, and to the owner of capital good profits. One looks to increasing the quantity of raw materials to be exported, and diminishing the inducements to the import of men, thus impoverishing both farmer and planter by throwing on them the burden of freight; while the other looks to increasing the import of men, and diminishing the export of raw materials, thereby enriching both planter and farmer by relieving them from the payment of freight. One looks to compelling the farmers and planters of the Union to continue their contributions for the support of the fleets and armies, the paupers, the nobles and the sovereigns of Europe; the other to enabling ourselves to apply the same means to the moral and intellectual improvement of the sovereigns of America. One looks to the continuance of that bastard freedom of trade which denies the principle of protection, yet doles it out as revenue duties; the other to extending the area of legitimate free trade by the establishment of perfect protection, followed by the annexation of individuals and communities, and ultimately by the abolition of custom-houses. One looks to exporting men to occupy desert tracts, the sovereignty of which is obtained by aid of diplomacy or war; the other to increasing the value of an immense extent of vacant land by importing men by millions for their occupation. One looks to increasing the necessity for commerce; the other to increasing the power to maintain it. One looks to underworking the Hindoo [sic], and sinking the rest of the world to his level; the other to raising the standard of man throughout the world to our level. One looks to pauperism, ignorance, depopulation, and barbarism; the other in increasing wealth, comfort, intelligence, combination of action, and civilization. One looks towards universal war; the other towards universal peace. One is the English system; the other we may be proud to call the American system, for it is the only one ever devised the tendency of which was that of elevating while equalizing the condition of man throughout the world.
Once again we see Republicans calling for workers of the world to unite, even using rhetoric reminiscent of historical dialectics.  A far cry from modern Republicans, who have fully bought into the "British System".

Today China, Japan, South Korea, and other nations pursue protectionist trade policies, while US and many European tariffs remain low due to free trade theorists winning the public debate.  Not only is the comparative advantage theory obsolete in this age of global capital flows, but it has obviously unbalanced the distribution of wealth between labor and capital in the developed world.  These faux progressives who advocate free trade today run under a false flag--the capital class rewards them with academic accolades and media play in order to make the public believe that free trade is in their interest.